Citizen’s Allowance in detail

Starting point: the tax system

Governments spend taxes in two ways:

  1. Redistribution: redistributing wealth from the few to the many. This includes health and education, as well as benefits and pensions, and is currently about three quarters of UK government spending; 
  2. Collective services: paying for services that cannot be delivered individually, such as roads and other infrastructure, policing, the armed services, the justice system, etc. 

In 2014-5 the amount of government spending on redistribution was approximately £500 billion. Spending on collective services was about £175 billion. Progressive tax relief (tax relief intended to assist in redistribution) was about £150 billion.

Why does redistribution spending include health and education?

Although health and education are regarded as basic public services, it is important to remember that traditionally they were paid for, and the state only began to provide them because most people could not afford them. This remains the case. Still today wealthy people buy private education and health provision, while everybody else relies on provision funded by taxation.

If spending on redistribution is added to progressive tax relief, the total is £650 billion. This is about £10,000 per person in the UK, which is the starting point for calculating the Citizen’s Allowance that each eligible person will receive. Out of this come payments for health and education, which is why it is given to eligible people of all ages.

In practice, different rates of citizen’s allowance are required for different people. Children require more, to fund their education; elderly people require more because they cannot supplement their income through work. The following table provides an outline of how the Citizen’s Allowance could be distributed.

Age range1st child U192nd and subsequent children U1919 – 67Over 67Total eligible population
Population3,747,33710,700,40240,967,9289,084,33364,500,000
Citizen’s allowance£15,000£12,000£10,000£12,000
Of which: NHS and social care contribution£1,000£1,000£3,000£3,000
Total health and social care funding£165 billion
Of which: education contribution£6,000£6,000£0£0
Total education funding£87 billion
Effective Citizen’s Allowance (after health and education contributions) per year£8,000£5,000£7,000£9,000

Citizen’s Allowance – some examples

Effective Citizen’s Allowance (after health and education contributions)AnnualWeekly
Single adult£7,000£135
Couple, no children£14,000£269
Single parent, 1 child£15,000£288
Single parent, 2 children£20,000£385
Family of 4£27,000£519
Single pensioner£9,000£173
Pensioner couple£18,000£346

Citizen’s Allowance is included in individual taxable income, and the Citizen’s Allowance for dependent children it added to the higher-paid parent’s income for this purpose. However tax is not generally payable when Citizen’s Allowance is the only income.

Citizen’s Allowance calculation – some explainers

The starting point for calculating the Citizen’s Allowance is the present tax system. The purpose of this is to demonstrate how it works within an established framework. It is likely, however, that its introduction will be accompanied by a revision of the existing system, introducing new taxes such as Financial Transaction Tax and Land Value Tax in order to make other taxes more progressive.

In particular, the Citizen’s Allowance makes the National Insurance system redundant. In practice this has been the case for many years; NI is simply a form of income tax by another name. The simple way forward is likely to be a combined income tax and NI calculated on the whole of an individual’s income (including the Citizen’s Allowance (after health and education contributions)) with a zero rate at £10,000, then increasing progressively as income increases.

Key requirements of the Citizen’s Allowance are that (i) it is at least as generous as the current pension system and (ii) that it addresses issues of child poverty. That is why the largest allowance goes to a first child.

The Citizen’s Allowance is not intended fully to replace Housing Benefit. The issue of affordable housing is addressed separately by the zero land cost housing policy.

The Citizen’s Allowance is not intended to replace the funding of social care, where this is currently funded by the state. Instead, about £30 billion of social care funding has been merged into the NHS and social care contribution.

A key expectation of the Citizen’s Allowance is that it will enable and encourage more people to undertake unpaid social care and childcare within their own families and communities. This will relieve pressure on the social care budget. Under the policy to reform measurement of the economy, such unpaid work will be counted as part of the economy on equal terms of its paid equivalent.

A detailed spreadsheet is available, showing how the Citizen’s Allowance has been calculated. This sets out the assumptions and variables, and offers the opportunity to experiment with different variables and distribution patterns.